Emergency Plumber in East Troy, WI

The answer depends on the unit's age and what failed. Below 8 years old: repair almost always makes sense unless the tank itself is leaking (tank leaks cannot be repaired - only the tank body holding the water). Between 8–12 years: evaluate the repair cost versus replacement. A failed heating element ($150–$250) is worth repairing. A failed thermostat ($100–$200) is worth repairing. A leaking tank or a repair that costs more than 50% of a new unit is the tipping point for replacement. Over 12 years with any internal failure: replacement is typically the right financial decision because the remaining life expectancy doesn't justify the repair cost. We give you the honest math, not the most profitable recommendation.

You can't know without a camera inspection - and any plumber who tells you to replace it without running a camera first is guessing at your expense. A sewer camera shows the interior condition of your line: root intrusion, grease blockage, pipe cracks, joint separation, pipe sag, or corrosion. Hydro jetting clears a line that is structurally intact. Pipe lining rehabilitates a line with surface cracks or minor deterioration. Full replacement is reserved for lines that have collapsed, severely bellied, or deteriorated beyond lining. The camera tells us which situation you're in and prevents guesswork.

Recurring clogs almost always mean the root cause was never identified - the drain was cleared of the blockage, but not of the reason it keeps forming. The most common causes of recurring drain issues are tree root intrusion in the main line (roots grow back after snaking), partial pipe collapse from soil movement, improper pipe slope that allows solids to settle, or significant grease accumulation that a snake can only punch through rather than clear. A sewer camera inspection shows exactly what's happening inside your drain. Once you know the actual problem, you can fix it permanently instead of paying for snaking every few months.

A drain snake (auger) is a rotating cable that physically breaks through or pulls out a blockage. It's effective for clearing a clog that's relatively close to the drain opening. It does not clean the pipe walls - it creates a hole through the obstruction and leaves grease, scale, and debris coating the interior. Hydro jetting uses pressurized water (up to 4,000 PSI) that scours the pipe walls completely clean, removing everything including biofilm and mineral deposits. Snaking is appropriate for a simple, first-time clog. Hydro jetting is the right choice for recurring blockages, significant grease buildup confirmed by camera, root intrusion that keeps returning, or pre-inspection preparation of a sewer line before lining.